Return to homepage

A Trip to the Theatre of Psychological Resilience: Heroic Tale or Melodrama?

Field notes
October 3, 2025

Dr Richard A.C. Simpson is a lecturer in psychology at Leeds Trinity University. Dr Simpson’s research examines human flourishing (well-being) in sport and performance contexts. With our new strand, Young LIFI talking about bouncing back, we asked Richard to write about resilience. 

Resilience is one of the most contested, yet widely used, concepts that occupies our everyday conversations. The root of the word ‘resilience’ can be traced back to the 1600s and the idea of “rebounding or springing back” borrowed from the Latin word Resiliens. Similar meanings to resilience can be seen across cultures, through the Finnish word Sissu, the French word ténacité, and other English synonyms (e.g., resistance, mental toughness, grit). To complicate this further, we may hear the term used across many domains such as Physics, Geology, Biology, and the various contexts where psychology operates (e.g., business, education, clinical, media, and sport). Drawing on the latter, psychological resilience is often used to understand how individuals, their relationships and teams, and communities, are faring when faced with challenge and adversity.

Given how frequently we hear about psychological resilience in everyday life, it is unsurprising that it has become a glamorised, and perhaps, unattainable expectation. Researchers have previously defined psychological resilience in many ways: as a trait, a process or adaptation, or qualities and resources that protect well-being. How can one bounce back from adversity? Be robust in the face of disruption? Or sustain well-being over time? A lot of research has often focused on “the high-performers”, the heroes who operate in high-pressure contexts, and the learnings that you can take away to demonstrate in your own context too. Already, we can start to see why public expectations around psychological resilience may walk a thin line between being a heroic or a melodramatic (i.e., over-the-top) tale.

Dr Richard A.C. Simpson is a lecturer in psychology at Leeds Trinity University

Common perceptions (e.g., seen within heroic tales), and misconceptions (e.g., that we supress rather than express emotions), around psychological resilience can lead to different ways in which stories about resilience are shaped, told, and celebrated. The iconic scene, for example, of Captain America facing Thanos and his army in Avengers Endgame. In the Wizard of Oz: the Scarecrow, Tinman, and the Lion go on a challenging quest to search for a brain, heart, and courage only to find they had it all along. Both stories are examples of heroic tales that can inspire audiences, and showcase themes of psychological resilience, but are we seeing limited depictions of what psychological resilience can look like? Rather than the heroism we are inspired by, does resilience risk becoming melodramatic?

Maybe the answer lies in broadening our expectations of what psychological resilience can look like and doing so in ways where unsung, everyday, relatable stories can be told. Better connecting to the ordinariness of day-to-day life and using newer words to map out experiential possibilities. Psychologists, for example, are starting to use words like ‘buoyancy’ (e.g., staying afloat in response to everyday challenges) and ‘anti-fragility’ (e.g., not just bouncing back but doing so in a way where you can grow and bounce back better).

Our experience of psychological resilience does not have to be heroic, visible or over the top, but should indeed be an attainable expectation that we can all develop and relate to in our day-to-day lives.

More posts

12 November, 2026 Field notes

LIFITV Episode 7: Denise van Outen and Miranda Sawyer on what the 90s really did to us

Britpop, Cool Britannia, dial-up internet and Euro 96. Everyone who was there has a story about the 90s, and it’s rarely a short one.

LIFITV Episode 7: Denise van Outen and Miranda Sawyer on what the 90s really did to us
9 November, 2026 Field notes

LIFITV Episode 6: Joe Tidy and Katy Leeson on whether it’s time to switch off social media

Most of us pick up our phones more than 100 times a day. We usually don’t notice we’re doing it, often don’t know why, and rarely put the phone down feeling any better.

LIFITV Episode 6: Joe Tidy and Katy Leeson on whether it’s time to switch off social media
5 November, 2026 Field notes

LIFITV Episode 5: Tasha Ghouri and Ash Palmisciano on being unapologetically you

Being yourself sounds simple. But between social media, school, work and everyone else’s expectations, it can feel harder than ever to know who that actually is, let alone be it out loud.

LIFITV Episode 5: Tasha Ghouri and Ash Palmisciano on being unapologetically you
2 November, 2026 Field notes

LIFITV Episode 4: Chris Packham on why we’re not acting fast enough

It’s easy to feel like the climate crisis is too big to do anything about. The headlines get worse, the warnings get louder, and it can feel like nothing we do will make any difference.

LIFITV Episode 4: Chris Packham on why we’re not acting fast enough